Research Article

Framing the 'Crisis': A Critical Discourse Analysis of Media Representation of Venezuelan Migrants in Colombian and Peruvian National Newspapers

126 reads
Jo On Re Mi St, 2026, 1 (1), 29-35, ISSN

Abstract

The Venezuelan forced displacement crisis constitutes the largest cross-border population movement in modern Latin American history, with over 7.7 million individuals displaced globally, predominantly hosted across South American nations. While public perception and policy responses to forced migration are heavily mediated by national news outlets, few comparative studies have critically examined media representations across distinct destination states within the Global South. This study presents a comparative Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) of 480 news articles published between 2018 and 2022 in major national dailies from the two primary recipient countries: Colombia (El Tiempo and El Espectador) and Peru (El Comercio and La República). Drawing on Norman Fairclough’s three-dimensional framework and Teun van Dijk’s socio-cognitive model, we interrogate how lexical selection, metaphorical framing, and discursive topoi construct the identities of Venezuelan migrants. The findings reveal a marked longitudinal shift from early humanitarian solidarity toward pervasive securitization and criminalization discourses. However, national differences persist: Peruvian media disproportionately deploy metaphors of inundation, disease, and existential security threats to legitimize restrictive border controls, whereas Colombian coverage demonstrates a fragmented discourse alternating between institutional integration narratives—aligned with regularisation policies—and localized crime reporting. This study illuminates how South-South migration narratives reproduce institutional xenophobia and shape public policy outcomes, emphasizing the necessity of ethical journalistic frameworks in forced displacement reporting.

Keywords media framing critical discourse analysis Securitization Venezuelan migration South-South displacement
Authors 2

The team behind this paper

2 authors, 2 institutions.

This paper School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS) — United Kingdom School of Oriental and … 1 author National Autonomous University of Mexico — Mexico National Autonomous Uni… 1 author Prof. Amina El-Sayed — corresponding author AE Prof. Amina El-Sayed ✉ Dr. Mateo Silva-Vargas MS Dr. Mateo Silva-Vargas

Readership

126 reads over 4 months.

#3 most read in this journal this month
August 2026 November 2026

Bibliographic Information

Prof. Amina El-Sayed, Dr. Mateo Silva-Vargas, (2026). Framing the 'Crisis': A Critical Discourse Analysis of Media Representation of Venezuelan Migrants in Colombian and Peruvian National Newspapers, SciMatic Journal of Ongoing Refugee and Migration Studies, 1(1): 29-35
Bibtex Citation
@article{prof._amina_el-sayed2026jorms,
author = {Prof. Amina El-Sayed and Dr. Mateo Silva-Vargas},
title = {Framing the 'Crisis': A Critical Discourse Analysis of Media Representation of Venezuelan Migrants in Colombian and Peruvian National Newspapers},
journal = {SciMatic Journal of Ongoing Refugee and Migration Studies},
year = {2026},
volume = {1},
number = {1},
pages = {29-35},
doi = {},
url = {https://scimatic.org/show_manuscript/9413}
}
APA Citation
El-Sayed, P.A., Silva-Vargas, D.M., (2026). Framing the 'Crisis': A Critical Discourse Analysis of Media Representation of Venezuelan Migrants in Colombian and Peruvian National Newspapers. SciMatic Journal of Ongoing Refugee and Migration Studies, 1(1), 29-35. https://doi.org/

Author Information

  • To change your profile photo, login to scimatic.org, go to your profile and change the photo.
  • Any photo that shows your face will do: we crop it to your head and shoulders and give it a plain background automatically.
  • To sign in, go to Sign in and enter the e-mail address registered with the article: we e-mail you a one-time sign-in link (there is no password).
  • In case of any other problem, contact your editor directly or write to us at info @ scimatic.org