Research Article

The Effect of Expert Testimony on Jury Perception of Battered Woman Syndrome: An Experimental Evaluation of Counterfactual Reasoning and Blame Attribution

128 reads
SciMatic J Forensic Crim Psychol, 2026, 1 (1), 26-32, ISSN

Abstract

This experimental study evaluated the influence of Battered Woman Syndrome (BWS) expert testimony on mock juror decision-making, focusing on counterfactual reasoning, blame attribution, and final verdict outcomes. A sample of 256 jury-eligible adults was randomly assigned to a 2 (Expert Testimony: Present vs. Absent) × 2 (Abuse Severity: High vs. Moderate) between-subjects factorial design based on a trial vignette involving a female defendant accused of killing her abusive partner during a non-confrontational lull in violence. Results revealed that the presence of BWS expert testimony significantly reduced the generation of victim-focused counterfactual thoughts (e.g., "If only she had left the relationship") and substantially decreased victim blame attribution. Furthermore, mediation analysis demonstrated that victim-focused counterfactual thinking served as a significant indirect mechanism through which expert testimony reduced guilty verdicts and increased self-defense acquittals. Abuse severity moderated these effects, with expert testimony exerting its strongest protective impact under moderate abuse conditions where juror skepticism was naturally higher. These findings demonstrate that forensic psychological expert testimony functions primarily by altering cognitive counterfactual framing, helping jurors contextualize non-confrontational self-defense and mitigate pervasive hindsight biases in intimate partner violence cases.

Keywords jury decision-making blame attribution Battered Woman Syndrome Expert Testimony Counterfactual Reasoning
Authors 3

The team behind this paper

3 authors, 3 institutions.

This paper King's College London — United Kingdom King's College London 1 author National Autonomous University of Mexico — Mexico National Autonomous Uni… 1 author Kyoto University — Japan Kyoto University 1 author Dr. Maya Lin-Vance — corresponding author ML Dr. Maya Lin-Vance ✉ Prof. Alejandro Gómez-Pérez AG Prof. Alejandro Gómez-Pér… Dr. Kenji Sato KS Dr. Kenji Sato

Readership

128 reads over 4 months.

August 2026 November 2026

Bibliographic Information

Dr. Maya Lin-Vance, Prof. Alejandro Gómez-Pérez, Dr. Kenji Sato, (2026). The Effect of Expert Testimony on Jury Perception of Battered Woman Syndrome: An Experimental Evaluation of Counterfactual Reasoning and Blame Attribution, SciMatic Journal of Forensic and Criminal Psychology, 1(1): 26-32
Bibtex Citation
@article{dr._maya_lin-vance2026sjfcp,
author = {Dr. Maya Lin-Vance and Prof. Alejandro Gómez-Pérez and Dr. Kenji Sato},
title = {The Effect of Expert Testimony on Jury Perception of Battered Woman Syndrome: An Experimental Evaluation of Counterfactual Reasoning and Blame Attribution},
journal = {SciMatic Journal of Forensic and Criminal Psychology},
year = {2026},
volume = {1},
number = {1},
pages = {26-32},
doi = {},
url = {https://scimatic.org/show_manuscript/9174}
}
APA Citation
Lin-Vance, D.M., Gómez-Pérez, P.A., Sato, D.K., (2026). The Effect of Expert Testimony on Jury Perception of Battered Woman Syndrome: An Experimental Evaluation of Counterfactual Reasoning and Blame Attribution. SciMatic Journal of Forensic and Criminal Psychology, 1(1), 26-32. https://doi.org/

Author Information

  • To change your profile photo, login to scimatic.org, go to your profile and change the photo.
  • Any photo that shows your face will do: we crop it to your head and shoulders and give it a plain background automatically.
  • To sign in, go to Sign in and enter the e-mail address registered with the article: we e-mail you a one-time sign-in link (there is no password).
  • In case of any other problem, contact your editor directly or write to us at info @ scimatic.org