Highly cross-linked, ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene (HXLPE) acetabular liners are inherently associated to a risk of fatigue failure due to femoral neck impingement. Different thicknesses and designs employed with HXLPE liners greatly affect mechanical loading scenario. The purpose of this study was to clarify the influence of liner offset (lateralization) and locking mechanism (presence/absence of anti-rotation tabs in the external surface) on fatigue durability in annealed and vitamin E-blended HXLPE liners with a current commercial design. Each liner tested had six anti-rotation tabs, which were engaged in the 6 of 12 recesses on the metal shell. The remaining six recesses had no direct contact with the liner, where HXLPE was mechanically unsupported by the metal backing. These mated and/or unmated rim regions in the offset (2, 3, 4-mm lateralized) liners were exposed to severe neck impingement until crack propagation was identified. Phase volume percentages (crystalline, amorphous, and intermediate phase contents) of HXLPE liners were compared before and after impingement in order to interpret differences in impingement micromechanics associated with the rim design variations. Our results showed that the presence of unmated recesses served as a stress concentrator due to the formation of millimeter-scale gaps between the liner and shell. Another potential design problem drawn from our study was liner offset associated with a small volume protruding above the metal rim. Therefore, surgeons should take special care in selecting locking designs and geometries especially when using HXLPE offset liners.