Pathogenic variants in presenilin 1 are related to early-onset Alzheimer disease (AD) and may occur as de novo variants. In comparison with sporadic forms, it can present with psychiatric manifestations, seizures, myoclonus, and focal presentation. Because PSEN1 can occur in young patients who lack a family history of neurologic disorders and because these symptoms are also frequent in autoimmune encephalitis (AE), diagnosis may be overlooked. Our aim was to demonstrate the challenge in diagnosing young patients with neurodegenerative diseases that simulate AE.We describe a case of a young patient with insidious progressive dementia, myoclonus, seizures, and aphasia, with no family history of dementia, along with signs suggestive of neuroinflammation on brain MRI and CSF examination.She was initially misdiagnosed as having AE. Further investigation was performed, leading to the discovery of a novel and de novo pathogenic variant in PSEN1.This case demonstrates the importance of considering PSEN1 in young patients with insidious progressive dementia with atypical clinical and neuroimaging features, even in patients without a family history of neurologic disorders. Not adhering to published criteria of possible and probable AE and overinterpretation of subtle inflammatory findings in CSF and MRI contribute to misdiagnosis.