Abstract Background The contamination of aquatic ecosystems with both anthropogenic pollutants and particles in particular (microscopic) plastic debris items is of emerging concern. Since plastic particles can accumulate contaminants and potentially facilitate their transport, it is important to properly investigate sorption mechanisms. This is especially required for a large variety of chemicals that can be charged under environmental conditions and for which interactions with particles may hence go beyond mere partitioning. Results In this study, sorption experiments with two types of microplastic particles (polyethylene and polystyrene) and 19 different contaminants (pesticides, pharmaceuticals, and personal care products) were performed at three different pH values. We could show that sorption to plastic particles is stronger for hydrophobic compounds and that neutral species usually contribute more to the overall sorption. Bulk partitioning coefficients were in the same order of magnitude for polyethylene and polystyrene. Furthermore, our results confirm that partition coefficients for polar compounds can only be accurately determined if the solid-to-liquid ratio in batch experiments is more than 6–7 orders of magnitude higher than any plastic concentration detected in the environment. Consequently, only a minor fraction of pollutants in water bodies is associated with microplastics. Conclusions Although neutral species primarily dominate the overall sorption, hydrophobic entities of ionic species cannot be neglected for some compounds. Notwithstanding, our results show that since microplastic concentrations as currently observed in the environment are very low, they are only a relevant sorbent for strongly hydrophobic but not for polar compounds.