Research Article

Street-Level Bureaucracy and Policy Implementation Discrepancies: A Qualitative Case Study of Ghana’s National Health Insurance Scheme

181 reads
SciMatic J Polit Sci Gov, 2026, 1 (1), 2-2, ISSN

Abstract

This study examines the role of street-level bureaucrats in the implementation of Ghana’s National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS), focusing on how discretionary decisions at the frontline lead to policy implementation discrepancies. Using Michael Lipsky’s street-level bureaucracy framework, we conducted a qualitative case study involving semi-structured interviews with frontline administrative staff, healthcare providers, and scheme subscribers in two selected districts in Ghana. The findings reveal that chronic resource constraints, inadequate training, delays in reimbursement, and high client-to-staff ratios compel frontline workers to employ various coping mechanisms, such as rationing services, informal prioritization, and unauthorized charging of copayments. These discretionary actions, while enabling bureaucrats to manage their daily workloads, significantly alter the formal policy objectives of the NHIS, resulting in inequitable access and reduced trust in the scheme. The study argues that policy success in developing governance contexts depends heavily on aligning top-down policy design with the bottom-up realities of frontline workers. We recommend systematic capacity building, timely financial disbursements, and formalized feedback loops between street-level implementers and national policy-makers to mitigate the gap between intended policy and actual practice.

Keywords policy implementation street-level bureaucracy Ghana NHIS Healthcare governance Discretionary coping
Authors 2

The team behind this paper

2 authors, 2 institutions.

This paper University of Abuja — Nigeria University of Abuja 1 author Uppsala University — Sweden Uppsala University 1 author Prof. Amara Okafor — corresponding author AO Prof. Amara Okafor ✉ Dr. Lene Reinhardt LR Dr. Lene Reinhardt

Readership

181 reads over 5 months.

#3 most read in this journal this month
July 2026 November 2026

Bibliographic Information

Prof. Amara Okafor, Dr. Lene Reinhardt, (2026). Street-Level Bureaucracy and Policy Implementation Discrepancies: A Qualitative Case Study of Ghana’s National Health Insurance Scheme, SciMatic Journal of Political Science and Governance, 1(1): 2-2
Bibtex Citation
@article{prof._amara_okafor2026sjpsg,
author = {Prof. Amara Okafor and Dr. Lene Reinhardt},
title = {Street-Level Bureaucracy and Policy Implementation Discrepancies: A Qualitative Case Study of Ghana’s National Health Insurance Scheme},
journal = {SciMatic Journal of Political Science and Governance},
year = {2026},
volume = {1},
number = {1},
pages = {2-2},
doi = {},
url = {https://scimatic.org/show_manuscript/8378}
}
APA Citation
Okafor, P.A., Reinhardt, D.L., (2026). Street-Level Bureaucracy and Policy Implementation Discrepancies: A Qualitative Case Study of Ghana’s National Health Insurance Scheme. SciMatic Journal of Political Science and Governance, 1(1), 2-2. https://doi.org/

Author Information

  • To change your profile photo, login to scimatic.org, go to your profile and change the photo.
  • Any photo that shows your face will do: we crop it to your head and shoulders and give it a plain background automatically.
  • To sign in, go to Sign in and enter the e-mail address registered with the article: we e-mail you a one-time sign-in link (there is no password).
  • In case of any other problem, contact your editor directly or write to us at info @ scimatic.org